The key term to a real estate private equity deal is the sponsor “promote”. It’s industry jargon – don’t you love fancy terms! – for the sponsor’s disproportionate share of profits in a real estate deal, provided the project hits certain return benchmarks.

Real And Money Flow
Money Vs Real Cash Flow
What Is Money Flow And Real Flow
Money Flow Vs Real Flow
Real Flow Vs Money Flow
Real Vs Money Flow

The promote is often expressed in the form of a waterfall. Equity waterfalls are one of the most difficult concepts to understand in all of real estate finance. Cash flows can be split in a countless number of ways, which is why real estate waterfall models can be so confusing. Even experienced practitioners have a hard time modeling these structures!

But it illustrates a few points about residential investment real estate, rental property value, rental income, real estate finance, and money in general. Evaluating cash vs. Cash is liquid money and is absolutely essential when you finance real estate. Cash is much easier to use if something goes wrong, whereas equity is completely.

What exactly is a “waterfall” when it comes to cash flow distributions?

An investment waterfall is a method of splitting profits amongst partners in a transaction that allows for profits to follow an uneven distribution. It can be thought of as a series of pools that fill up with cash flow and then once full, spill over all excess cash flow into additional pools.

This type of arrangement is beneficial because it allows the equity investors to reward the sponsor with an extra (disproportionate) share of returns. This extra share of returns is the promote, which is used as a bonus to motivate the sponsor to exceed return expectations.

Under the waterfall structure, the sponsor will receive a higher share of profits if the project’s return is higher than expected, and a lower share of profits if the project’s return is lower than expected.

Real And Money Flow

Risk Management: Alignment of Interests Between the Investors and Sponsors

Figure 1: Money Flow Index of CTRP Fluctuating Between the 0 and 100 Levels. When a stock’s price rises, the money flow index indicator also rises and is a sign of increased buying pressure. Conversely, if the stock price drops, the money flow index indicator will also decline and is a sign of selling pressure.
Money flow: The money flow refers to the flow of factor payments from firms to households for factor services. Similarly, the flow of consumption expenditure from households to firms for the purchase of goods and services manufactured by the firms. Give three differences between real flow and money flow.
Source: High Yield Landlord Real Money Portfolio Compared to traditional equities, our real asset portfolio also enjoys much more reasonable valuation metrics trading at 9.5x cash flow on average.

The waterfall structure can also be viewed as a risk-management tool as it allows the downside risk to be shifted away from the equity investor while providing upside potential to the sponsor. It can come in different flavors but the internal rate of return (IRR) is the most popular method that accomplishes these goals.

The various stakeholders in the capital stack – debt investors, equity investors, sponsors – always jockey for a position in splitting profits. The traditional structure represents an inverse hierarchy of risk and payment priority.

The debt investors (or lender) has the first repayment priority and the lowest level of risk. In exchange, they accept a predetermined return or a predetermined interest rate.

Next in line are the equity investors. Assuming a simple capital stack, the equity investors are the ones who invest capital and are subject to a fluctuating return depending on the project’s success.

Finally, the sponsor, who may also be an equity investor, takes on the highest level of risk. While their skill, tenacity and vision are pivotal to the project’s success, the sponsor’s return is typically subordinate to the lender’s and equity investor’s. But they also have the highest upside potential to account for the high level of risk they are undertaking.

The typical waterfall solves this situation by positively compensating the sponsor for a successful project, while, at the same time, minimizing the downside risk for the equity investor.

The concept is simple but effective: if the returns are greater than expected, a disproportionate share flows to the sponsor but if the returns are lower than expected, a disproportionate share flows to the equity investors. This allows for the risk and return to be distributed in a more equitable manner. The lender always gets paid before the sponsor or the equity investor.

The Importance of the Owner’s Agreement

In most cases, the details around the waterfall or any other means of cash flow splits is outlined in the owner’s agreement. The entire structure is based on the “return hurdle” which is a specific amount of profit that the project needs to generate to progress to the next hurdle.

It is critical to read the owner’s agreement, as there are a multitude of variables when it comes to investment waterfall structures. At the minimum, the agreement should spell out, in detail, how the cash flows will be split among the partners.

There are some commonly used terms and components in investment waterfall structures. Nonetheless, waterfall structures can and do vary. This means that there is no “one-size-fits-all” solution. The only way to understand the specific waterfall structure is to read the owner’s agreement.

Common Waterfall Components

Return hurdle
As mentioned above, the return hurdle is a rate of return that must be achieved before moving to the next hurdle. This is important to understand as the return hurdles (also called tiers) are what trigger the disproportionate splits.

The return hurdles can be defined in many ways. They are most commonly expressed as the IRR or equity multiple. The IRR is the percentage rate earned on each dollar invested for each invested period. The equity multiple is expressed as the aggregate of invested equity and all profits divided by invested equity.

Once the return hurdle has been defined, the next question is: from what perspective will the return be measured?

The returns can be calculated from different perspectives including the project, 3rd party investor equity or sponsor equity. Sponsors have been known to get very creative when designing the return hurdles.

Preferred Return
The preferred return is defined as a first claim on profits until a target return has been achieved. In simpler words, preferred investors in a project are first in line and will earn the preferred return before any other investor receives a distribution. Excess profits can be split once the preferred return hurdle has been met.

This leads to a few key questions (details taken from this excellent post):

– Who gets the preferred return?

Preferred return investors could include all equity investors or only select equity investors. At the institutional-level, the senior-most equity source might get a distribution first before the cash is distributed to anyone else.

– Is the preferred return cumulative?

Non-sophisticated investors often don’t even know about cumulative preferred returns. They become relevant if there isn’t enough cash flow to pay out the preferred return in any given year.

In waterfall models, this preferred return can either be cumulative or non-cumulative. If the preferred return is cumulative, then it will be added to the investment balance for the next period and accumulate until it is eventually paid out.

– Is the preferred return compounded?

Again, another concept often overlooked by newer, less sophisticated investors.

A preferred return can be compounded or non-compounded. A key question arises when the preferred return is cumulative.

Is the unpaid cash compounded at the preferred return as it accumulates?

In other words, does the sponsor pay an interest on the unpaid preferred return, at the preferred rate of return?

Compounded interest means that the investor gets paid an interest on the accrued preferred return. Hence, they are compensated for the inconvenience of not being paid the preferred return on time.

As Einstein remarked, “Compound interest is the 8th wonder of the world.”

– What is the compounding peri

Real Vs Money Flow